Contact our office:

(503) 765-7615
logistics@crisis-medicine.com
Login
Crisis Medicine
  • Training
    • TCCC and TECC Concepts
    • Training for Fire & EMS
    • Training for Law Enforcement
    • Training for EDC
    • Training for Private Citizens
    • Training For Faith Communities
    • Training For Teachers
  • Courses
    • Preview Course
    • Course Overview By Skills
    • ONLINE TCCC & TECC Courses
    • Student Reviews
    • In-Person Trainings
  • Company
    • About Crisis Medicine
    • Agency Pricing
    • Contact
    • CM in the Media
    • Disclosures – None
    • Lessons Learned in Blood
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Learn
    • New
    • Quick Tips
    • MARCH
      • (S) Security & Awareness
      • (M) Massive Hemorrhage
      • (A) Airway
      • (R) Respiration
      • (C) Circulation
      • (H) Hypothermia Prevention
    • Equipment
    • Improvised
    • Casualty Movement
    • More
    • Tactical CBRN
    • Planning Your IFAK
  • Shop
    • Cart

      0

(M) Massive Hemorrhage

Single vs Double Routing of the Eyelet on the CAT Tourniquet

  • Posted by Mike Shertz
  • Categories (M) Massive Hemorrhage, Equipment
  • Date January 11, 2018
A photo showing the small time savings of using a single routed 7th gen CAT vs a 6th generation double eyelet routing.

Change in CAT tourniquets from 6th to 7th generation

In October 2015, the 6th generation Combat Application Tourniquet, or CAT, with its double-eyelet buckle was discontinued, in favor of the 7th generation CAT which has only a single-eyelet routed buckle. In 2013, Dr. Kragh published an article citing a 23% rate of CAT tourniquets with the double-eyelet buckle being single-eyelet routed on lower extremity applications for hemorrhage control. Although this tourniquet technique is appropriate when self-applying the CAT on an upper extremity, proper lower extremity application required routing the tourniquet band through both holes of the double-eyelet. This secured the tourniquet with both friction through the double eyelet and with the Velcro band.

imageDr. Kragh showed on a computerized manikin tourniquet trainer that it was 7 seconds faster to apply the CAT to the manikin’s injured leg if the tourniquet was single routed as opposed to double routed. That time savings equaled 51 ml less blood-loss with the single routing, based on the simulated bleeding rate of the manikin. (Those were the mean or “average” results.)

Actual differences in application time

However, the median differences (middle result, with as many results above and below it, not the mean/average where one big result/number pushes the entire mean upward) was a time difference of 3.5 seconds, favoring the single routing. The single routing resulted in a median decrease of only 8 ml of simulated blood loss, representing only about 1.5 teaspoons less blood or the equivalent of three Vacutainer®1 tubes (much less than the typical five to eight tubes of blood drawn on initial trauma center evaluation).

image

Although in concept, any technique that decreases blood loss is a good thing, there are always trade-offs. In this case, using the single routed eyelet for leg application requires reliance on only the Velcro of the tourniquet band to hold pressure. If the Velcro fails or releases, the entire tourniquet would disengage with catastrophic results.

Dr. Kragh stated as long as 1.6 inches of Velcro on the tourniquet was adhered, it would hold. Unfortunately, that has not been our experience in training, where such a short piece of attached Velcro frequently fails, especially when dragging casualties to safety.

Training issue or design issue?

Instead of calling the incorrect single-eyelet leg applications a tourniquet training issue, the military, armed with Dr. Kragh’s study showing decreased blood loss, demanded the CAT be redesigned to eliminate the need to route the tourniquet through the double-eyelet on legs. This lead to the redesigned “7th generation” CAT.

One could argue that such a significant design change renders all of the previously studied volunteer and combat applications of the CAT tourniquet irrelevant. In turn, that means the 7th generation CAT is technically unproven, as those kinds of studies don’t yet exist proving success of that device. Of course, the same argument can be applied to the current (2nd) generation of the recently redesigned SOFT-Wide.

Conclusion? Velcro can fail.

Until more literature is available, we are in no hurry to replace our 6th generation CAT tourniquets. Velcro fails. That is why the leg and chest straps on your parachute harnesses aren’t secured with just Velcro…

Don’t take our word for it, read the article, not just the abstract or their conclusions:

Single versus Double Routing of the Band in the Combat Application, BR Clumpner,Polston RW, Kragh et al, J Spec Oper Med. 2013 Spring;13(1):34-41. Single versus Double Routing of the Band in the Combat Application Tourniquet.

1 Vacutainer® is a registered trademark of Becton, Dickinson and Company.

Sign up for a free preview course

We never share your information.
Check to agree to our privacy policy

  • Share:
Mike Shertz

Dr. Mike Shertz is the Owner and Lead Instructor at Crisis Medicine. Dr. Shertz spent over 30 years gaining the experience and insight to create and provide his comprehensive, science-informed, training to better prepare everyday citizens, law enforcement, EMS, and the military to manage casualties and wounded in high-risk environments. Using a combination of current and historical events, Dr. Shertz’s lectures include relevant, illustrative photos, as well as hands-on demonstrations to demystify the how, why, when to use each emergency medical procedure you need to become a Force Multiplier for Good.

Previous post

Japanese Samurai Woodblock Print
January 11, 2018

Next post

Improvised Pant-leg Pelvic Binder
January 22, 2018

You may also like

2 King CAT SQ
Mayhem in the Nutcracker Suite
12 December, 2021
A photo of a police officer's leg showing two, side-by-side CAT tourniquets properly applied to stop massive hemorrhage
Tourniquets: One may not be enough
10 September, 2021
A photo of the burly chest of an operator with an American flag and CAT tourniquet staged on the exterior of his gear, center line
Tourniquet environmental wear: is time of the essence?
11 August, 2021

Featured Courses

Tactical Casualty Care – ONLINE

Tactical Casualty Care – ONLINE

$125.00
Advanced TC2 – ONLINE

Advanced TC2 – ONLINE

$350.00
Complete TC2 -ONLINE

Complete TC2 -ONLINE

$575.00

Sign up for a free preview course

We never share your information.
Check to agree to our privacy policy

Crisis Medicine

(503) 765-7615

logistics@crisis-medicine.com

DUNS: 093140133

CAGE: 8U3A3

Company

  • About Crisis Medicine
  • Disclosures
  • Training Partners & Contributors

Courses

  • Online Training
  • In-Person Training
  • Content Warning
  • FAQ’s

Fine Print

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Content Warning
  • Scope of Practice
  • Contact

Resources

  • N. Amer. Rescue
  • TacMed Solutions
  • Chinook Medical
  • Skedco
  • Wound Cube

©2022 Crisis Medicine, all rights reserved.

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Sitemap

Login with your site account

Lost your password?