Contact our office:

(503) 765-7615
logistics@crisis-medicine.com
Login
Crisis Medicine
  • Training
    • TCCC and TECC Concepts
    • Training for Fire & EMS
    • Training for Law Enforcement
    • Training for EDC
    • Training for Private Citizens
    • Training For Faith Communities
    • Training For Teachers
  • Courses
    • Preview Course
    • Course Overview By Skills
    • ONLINE TCCC & TECC Courses
    • Student Reviews
    • In-Person Trainings
    • Agency Pricing
  • Company
    • Contact
    • About Crisis Medicine
    • CM in the Media
    • Lessons Learned in Blood
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Articles
    • New
    • MARCH
      • (S) Security & Awareness
      • (M) Massive Hemorrhage
      • (A) Airway
      • (R) Respiration
      • (C) Circulation
      • (H) Hypothermia Prevention
    • Equipment
    • Improvised
    • Casualty Movement
    • More
  • Shop
    • Cart

      0

(M) Massive Hemorrhage

Head to head: Doppler vs. Pulse oximeter as a training tool for tourniquet efficacy. Doppler wins.

  • Posted byMike Shertz
  • Categories(M) Massive Hemorrhage
  • Date February 12, 2021
  • Comments0 comment
A CAT tourniquet, Nonin Pulse Ox, and Doppler displayed on a table

BLUF:* Is there a role for using a fingertip pulse oximeter as a training tool for tourniquet placement? We believe the answer is no. Considering the relative expense of a quality, FDA approved model pulse ox, a handheld doppler ultrasound is better, cheaper, provides audible pulsation feedback, and is the acknowledged standard.

Proper limb tourniquet application implies no arterial blood flow past the point of tourniquet application. In training, the loss of a palpable downstream pulse is often used as a marker of successful tourniquet tightness. However, an arterial pulse’s ability to be felt with fingers is lost long before the complete cessation of arterial flow through the artery.

As an example, although the exact numbers are argued, a radial pulse is no longer palpable when the arterial blood pressure through the artery drops below 80 mmHg.1 Although this is only 2/3 of normal blood pressure, it is far from no flow and in an injured artery would still represent substantial ongoing hemorrhage.

To improve accuracy and better understand how tightly tourniquets need to be placed to occlude arterial flow, some advocate using a fingertip pulse oximeter as a monitor of distal blood flow. However, pulse oximeters are designed to display accurate arterial oxygen saturations, not the presence of weak arterial flow.1

In a study by Wall, et al.2, three pulse oximeters were compared to doppler ultrasound for their ability to detect loss of arterial flow after volunteer tourniquet application to both arms and legs. None of the tested pulse oximeters were of the “fingertip” type. All were somewhat large monitors with the finger saturation probe attached to the monitor by wire cable. These tabletop models are more accurate versions than the pocket/aid bag friendly, Nonin-type, pulse oximeters.

As the tourniquet was tightened, in all of the pulse oximeter devices tested, the signal was lost before the doppler registered no detachable flow. When all three pulse oximeters were placed on the same limb, they corresponded with one another only 80% of the time as to whether a pulse was present.

The accuracy of the pulse oximeter readings were highly variable between monitors and in application to finger versus toes. In general, the devices were much less accurate on toes.

Interestingly, the sensitivity of the pulse oximeters varied between 75 to 92% compared to doppler. Their specificity was only 44 to 83%. A low specificity test means there are a lot of false-positive results. In this case, the oximeter read “no flow,” when actually, arterial flow persisted.

Dr. Wall’s study conclusion? Doppler is the de facto gold standard for noninvasive monitoring of tourniquet effectiveness.

Is there a role for using a fingertip pulse oximeter as a training tool for tourniquet placement? We believe the answer is no. Even a quality fingertip model shows decreased accuracy overall, and particularly on toes (high thigh tourniquet application having the highest failure rate in real-world applications). Considering the relative expense of a quality, FDA approved model pulse ox, a handheld doppler ultrasound is better, cheaper, provides audible pulsation feedback, and is the acknowledged standard.

Notes:

*For those unfamiliar with this term, BLUF is “Bottom Line Up Front,”

1 Deakin CD, Low JL. Accuracy of the advanced trauma life support guidelines for predicting systolic blood pressure using carotid, femoral, and radial pulses: observational study. BMJ. 2000;321(7262):673-674.

2 Wall PL, Buising CM, Grulke L, Troester A, Bianchina N, White S, Freymark R, Hassan A, Hopkins JW, Renner CH, Sahr SM. Effectiveness of Pulse Oximetry Versus Doppler for Tourniquet Monitoring. J Spec Oper Med. 2017 Spring;17(1):36-44.

Sign up for a free preview course

We never share your information.
Check to agree to our privacy policy

  • Share:
Mike Shertz

Dr. Mike Shertz is the Owner and Lead Instructor at Crisis Medicine. Dr. Shertz spent over 30 years gaining the experience and insight to create and provide his comprehensive, science-informed, training to better prepare everyday citizens, law enforcement, EMS, and the military to manage casualties and wounded in high-risk environments. Using a combination of current and historical events, Dr. Shertz’s lectures include relevant, illustrative photos, as well as hands-on demonstrations to demystify the how, why, when to use each emergency medical procedure you need to become a Force Multiplier for Good.

Previous post

Powerful TECC/TCCC uses for a fingertip pulse oximeter
February 12, 2021

You may also like

Hip Blood Suppy
Best Practices: Tourniquets & Closed Femur Fractures?
21 January, 2021
2021 01 11 Meg Just CLEAN
Deputy receives Lifesaver Award one month after online training and credits Crisis Medicine
15 January, 2021
Dr. Shertz with Frank the Manikin pre-filming for using a necktie as an improvised tourniquet
A necktie as an improvised tourniquet? Yup. Doppler Proven.
24 June, 2020

Leave A Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Featured Courses

Tactical Casualty Care – ONLINE

Tactical Casualty Care – ONLINE

$125.00
Advanced TC2 – ONLINE

Advanced TC2 – ONLINE

$350.00
Complete TC2 -ONLINE

Complete TC2 -ONLINE

$575.00

Sign up for a free preview course

We never share your information.
Check to agree to our privacy policy

Crisis Medicine

(503) 765-7615

logistics@crisis-medicine.com

Company

  • About Crisis Medicine
  • Disclosures
  • Training Partners & Contributors

Courses

  • Online Training
  • In-Person Training
  • Content Warning
  • FAQ’s

Fine Print

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Content Warning
  • Scope of Practice
  • Contact

Resources

  • TECC
  • NA Rescue
  • TacMed Solutions
  • Chinook Medical
  • Skedco
  • Wound Cube

©2021 Crisis Medicine, all rights reserved.

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Sitemap

Login with your site account

Lost your password?